Introduction
The burden of musculoskeletal disease poses a significant global health challenge, with low-and middle-income countries (LMICs) being particularly affected, resulting in approximately 90% of trauma-related deaths worldwide [
1The global burden of musculoskeletal injuries: challenges and solutions.
,
2The World Health Organization's action plan on the road traffic injury pandemic: is there any action for orthopaedic trauma surgeons?.
,
3- Hofman K.
- Primack A.
- Keusch G.
- Hyrnkow S.
Addressing the growing burden of trauma and injury in low-and middle-income countries.
]. Open tibial shaft fractures are one of the most frequently reported traumatic injuries, and are associated with high rates of infection, nonunion, and malunion [
[1]The global burden of musculoskeletal injuries: challenges and solutions.
]. Road traffic accidents have contributed to the rise in the incidence of open tibia fractures, which has led to over 50,000 open fractures per year in some Latin American countries, with complication rates reaching as high as 20% [
[4]Traffic accidents scar Latin America's roads.
,
[5]- Orihuela-Fuchs V.A.
- Fuentes-Figueroa S.
Infection rate in open fractures adjusted for the degree of exposure.
].
Due to the high-velocity trauma associated with many open tibia fractures, these injuries are often complicated by soft-tissue damage, which can be exacerbated by poor and untimely wound coverage that can lead to further complications including infection, amputation, and death [
[6]Injuries: the neglected burden in developing countries.
,
[7]- Carey J.N.
- Caldwell A.M.
- Coughlin R.R.
- Hansen S.
Building orthopaedic trauma capacity: IGOT international SMART course.
]. In high-income countries (HICs), these soft-tissue interventions are often delegated to the expertise of plastic surgeons. However, in LMICs there is a dearth of plastic surgeons available to treat soft-tissue injuries, and therefore these wounds are managed by orthopaedic surgeons or other healthcare providers who often lack sufficient training [
[8]- Townley W.A.
- Nguyen D.Q.A.
- Rooker J.C.
- Dickson J.K.
- Goroszeniuk D.Z.
- Khan M.S.
- et al.
Management of open tibial fractures - a regional experience.
].
Multiple measures have been suggested to address this gap in the management of soft-tissue injury following open tibia fractures, such as standard of care protocols, academic partnerships, and international soft-tissue coverage training courses [
[9]- Wu H.H.
- Kushal P.R.
- Caldwell A.M.
- Coughlin R.R.
- Hansen S.L.
- Carey J.N.
Surgical management and reconstruction training (SMART) course for international orthopedic surgeons.
]. However, these measures are not well documented across Latin America. In a recent study, it was reported that few middle-income countries (MICs) had standard of care protocols or guidelines in place for open fracture treatment in Latin America [
[10]- Miclau T.
- Hoogervorst P.
- Shearer D.W.
- El Naga A.
- Working Z.
- Martin C.
- et al.
Current status of musculoskeletal trauma care systems worldwide.
,
[11]- Albright P.D.
- MacKechnie M.C.
- Jackson J.H.
- Chopra A.
- Holler J.T.
- Flores Biard A.
- et al.
Knowledge deficits and barriers to performing soft-tissue coverage procedures: an analysis of participants in an orthopaedic surgical skills training course in Mexico.
]. The current paucity of literature on soft-tissue management for open traumatic wounds in this region poses a significant challenge in identifying needs, comparing treatment strategies, and determining effective solutions across a diverse economic landscape. Thus, the purpose of this study was to examine soft-tissue coverage techniques of open tibia fractures, describe soft-tissue treatment patterns across income groups, and determine resource accessibility and availability in Latin America.
Discussion
Determining the ideal protocol for open fracture treatment in Latin America is considered one of the top health research priorities in musculoskeletal care [
[15]- Roberts H.J.
- MacKechnie M.C.
- Shearer D.W.
- Segovia Altieri J.
- de la Huerta F.
- Rio M.W.
- et al.
Orthopaedic trauma research priorities in Latin America: developing consensus through a modified delphi.
], with timeliness and method of treatment being critical to the function and outcome of these injuries [
[16]- Cross III, W.
- Swiontkowski M.F.
Treatment principles in the management of open fractures.
,
[17]- Hertel R.
- Lambert S.M.
- Muller S.
- Ballmer F.T.
- Ganz R.
On the timing of soft-tissue reconstruction for open fractures of the lower leg.
]. This study adds to recent research on open tibia fracture management in Latin America by identifying soft-tissue coverage techniques, timing, and available resources across HICs and MICs.
Countries in Latin America have large disparities in healthcare expenditures in relation to their Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita, ranging from 3.5%−11.2%, resembling similar percentages to those observed in low, middle, and high-income countries [
,
[19]OECD iLibrary
Health at a Glance: Latin America and the Caribbean.
]. Socioeconomic factors, as well as diverse national healthcare systems in this region, contribute to the uneven distribution of musculoskeletal trauma care across centers, disproportionately impacting those in resource-limited settings [
[6]Injuries: the neglected burden in developing countries.
,
20- Padilla Rojas L.G.
- Lopez Cervantes R.E.
- Perez Atanasio J.M.
- Martinez Sanchez M.
- Gomez Acevedo J.M.
- Kojima K.E
Latin America trauma systems - Mexico and Brazil.
,
21Trauma - the forgotten pandemic?.
,
22- Arreola-Risa C.
- Mock C.N.
- Lojero-Wheatly L.
- de la Cruz O.
- Garcia C.
- Canavati-Ayub F.
- et al.
Low-cost improvements in prehospital trauma care in a Latin American City.
,
23- Arreola-Risa C.
- Mock C.
- Vega Rivera F.
- Romero Hicks E.
- Guzmán Solana F.
- Porras Ramírez G.
- et al.
Evaluating trauma care capabilities in Mexico with the World Health Organization's guidelines for essential trauma care.
,
24- Mock C.
- Joshipura M.
- Goosen J.
- Maier R.
Overview of the essential trauma care project.
].
In this study, plastic surgeons in HICs were more commonly cited as the primary providers responsible for performing soft-tissue coverage than in MICs. Of note, a small percentage of respondents reported no access to orthopaedic or plastic surgeons to provide soft-tissue coverage for GA Type IIIB open tibia fractures, likely requiring the patient to be referred to a more well-equipped hospital with specialists and resources. Plastic surgeons were also reportedly more accessible in HICs than MICs, consistent with prior literature citing lack of access to specialists as a major barrier to performing wound coverage in LMICs [
[6]Injuries: the neglected burden in developing countries.
,
[11]- Albright P.D.
- MacKechnie M.C.
- Jackson J.H.
- Chopra A.
- Holler J.T.
- Flores Biard A.
- et al.
Knowledge deficits and barriers to performing soft-tissue coverage procedures: an analysis of participants in an orthopaedic surgical skills training course in Mexico.
,
25- Albright P.D.
- MacKechnie M.C.
- Roberts H.J.
- Shearer D.W.
- Padilla Rojas L.G.
- Quintero J.E.
- et al.
Open tibial shaft fractures: treatment patterns in Latin America.
,
26- Grimes C.E.
- Bowman K.G.
- Dodgion C.M.
- Lavy C.B.
Systematic review of barriers to surgical care in low-income and middle-income countries.
,
27Expanding the orthopaedic training programme to improve the management of lower extremity trauma.
,
28- Mishra B.
- Koirala R.
- Tripathi N.
- Raj Shrestha K.
- Adhikary B.
- Shah S
Plastic surgery - myths and realities in developing countries: experience from eastern Nepal.
]. Indeed, in Latin America, a prior study reported that soft-tissue flaps are not performed in nearly one-third of GA Type IIIB fractures due to these barriers [
[25]- Albright P.D.
- MacKechnie M.C.
- Roberts H.J.
- Shearer D.W.
- Padilla Rojas L.G.
- Quintero J.E.
- et al.
Open tibial shaft fractures: treatment patterns in Latin America.
]. Although the orthopaedic surgeon-respondents across HICs and MICs in this study received similar levels of soft-tissue training, the greater availability and access to specialist coverage in HICs was associated with timelier definitive treatment (within seven days) than in MICs, supporting the advantages of a combined orthoplastic team. Other barriers that may factor into time to definitive soft-tissue coverage between income groups include individual surgeon expertise, medical cost, implant and equipment availability, hospital resources, and infrastructure [
[29]- Holler J.T.
- Albright P.
- Challa S.
- Ali S.H.
- Keys K.
- et al.
Barriers to performing soft tissue reconstruction procedures among orthopedic surgeons in low- and middle-income countries: results of a surgical skills training course.
].
Multidisciplinary management between orthopaedic and plastic surgery teams is advantageous for the treatment of severe open tibia fractures, as it is associated with timelier treatment, quicker recovery, and less complications [
30- Naique S.B.
- Pearse M.
- Nanchahal J.
Management of severe open tibial fractures: the need for combined orthopaedic and plastic surgical treatment in specialist centres.
,
31- Gopal S.
- Majumder S.
- Batchelor A.G.
- et al.
Fix and flap: the radical orthopaedic and plastic treatment of severe open fractures of the tibia.
,
32- Kuripla C.
- Tornetta III, P.
- Foote C.J.
- Koh J.
- Sems A.
- Shamaa T.
- et al.
Timing of flap coverage with respect to definitive fixation in open tibia fractures.
,
33- VandenBerg J.
- Osei D.
- Boyer M.I.
- Gardner M.J.
- Ricci W.M.
- Spraggs-Hughes A.
- et al.
Open tibia shaft fractures and soft-tissue coverage: the effects of management by an orthopaedic trauma/microsurgical team.
]. Plastic surgeons play a critical role in trauma centers performing limb-saving flap procedures, skin grafts, and microsurgery. Given these benefits, combined specialty teams are recognized in national open fracture treatment guidelines in Europe and North America [
34The management of skeletal trauma in the United Kingdom.
,
35- Orthopaedic Trauma Association
American College of Surgeons
Best practices in the management of orthopaedic trauma.
,
36- Nanchahal J.
- Nayagam S.
- Khan U.
- Moran C.
- Barrett S.
- Sanderson F.
- et al.
Standards for the management of open fractures of the lower limb (British association of plastic reconstructive and aesthetic surgeons).
]. Yet, many guidelines in Latin America are neither well-described nor standardized across the region [
[20]- Padilla Rojas L.G.
- Lopez Cervantes R.E.
- Perez Atanasio J.M.
- Martinez Sanchez M.
- Gomez Acevedo J.M.
- Kojima K.E
Latin America trauma systems - Mexico and Brazil.
,
[25]- Albright P.D.
- MacKechnie M.C.
- Roberts H.J.
- Shearer D.W.
- Padilla Rojas L.G.
- Quintero J.E.
- et al.
Open tibial shaft fractures: treatment patterns in Latin America.
]. Using evidence-based standardized guidelines, such as the British Association of Plastic Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons (BAPRAS) [
[36]- Nanchahal J.
- Nayagam S.
- Khan U.
- Moran C.
- Barrett S.
- Sanderson F.
- et al.
Standards for the management of open fractures of the lower limb (British association of plastic reconstructive and aesthetic surgeons).
], could help guide the development of regional protocols that include definitive soft-tissue coverage within seven days, “fix and flap” soft-tissue coverage with concomitant definitive fixation, and NPWT as an adjunct to open fracture management, all of which surgeons in HICs and MICs could work towards to improve outcomes and decrease complications [
[37]- Elniel A.R.
- Giannoudis P.V.
Open fractures of the lower extremity: current management and clinical outcomes.
]. Some principles of lower extremity management outlined in these guidelines, including wound debridement within 24 h of injury and antibiotic administration within 3 h of injury for GA Type I-III fractures, are already reported as common practice among orthopaedic surgeons in Latin America [
[25]- Albright P.D.
- MacKechnie M.C.
- Roberts H.J.
- Shearer D.W.
- Padilla Rojas L.G.
- Quintero J.E.
- et al.
Open tibial shaft fractures: treatment patterns in Latin America.
].
While standard orthopaedic residency training typically does not include soft-tissue flap coverage techniques as part of their core curriculum, this study's findings provide perspective on current training and practices in this region, which can aid in the development of solutions to address treatment gaps. Efforts to train orthopaedic surgeons that acutely manage open tibia fractures with wound defects has been shown to be a cost-effective way of addressing these complex injuries in lesser-resourced settings [
[38]- Grimes C.E.
- Henry J.A.
- Maraka J.
- Mkandawire N.C.
- Cotton M.
Cost-effectiveness of surgery in low-and middle-income countries: a systematic review.
,
[39]- Carlson L.A.
- Slobogean G.P.
- Pollak A.N.
Orthopaedic trauma care in Haiti: a cost-effectiveness analysis of an innovative surgical residency program.
]. Specifically, hands-on reconstructive training courses in these environments, led by both orthopaedic and plastic surgeons, can augment surgeons’ knowledge and skill in managing rotational flaps, skin grafts, and wound management [
[9]- Wu H.H.
- Kushal P.R.
- Caldwell A.M.
- Coughlin R.R.
- Hansen S.L.
- Carey J.N.
Surgical management and reconstruction training (SMART) course for international orthopedic surgeons.
,
[29]- Holler J.T.
- Albright P.
- Challa S.
- Ali S.H.
- Keys K.
- et al.
Barriers to performing soft tissue reconstruction procedures among orthopedic surgeons in low- and middle-income countries: results of a surgical skills training course.
,
40- Challa S.
- Conway D.
- Hao Hua Wu
- Bisht R.
- Sherchan B.
- Lamichhane A.
- et al.
Can a 2-day course teach orthopaedic surgeons rotational flap procedures? An evaluation of data from the Nepal SMART course over 2 years.
,
41- Peter N.A.
- Pandit H.
- Le G Nduhiu M.
- Moro E.
- Lavy C.
Delivering a sustainable trauma management training programme tailored for low-resource settings in East, Central and Southern Africa countries using a cascading course.
,
42- Singh J.
- Dhillon M.S.
- Dhatt S.S.
Single-Stage “Fix and Flap” Gives Good Outcomes in Grade 3B/C Open Tibial fractures: a prospective study.
].
Less than half of the study participants reported having access to various instruments in the operating room, including magnifying loupes, wall suction, Humby blades, and power dermatomes. NPWT was the only resource available to the majority of orthopaedic surgeons. Though previously believed to decrease infection rates of severe open wounds, a 2018 Cochrane review and a large randomized controlled trial showed no clear differences in healing or infection rates in open fractures in comparison to conventional dressings [
[43]- Iheozor-Ejiofor Z.
- Newton K.
- Dumville J.C
- Costa M.L.
- Normal G.
- Bruce J.
Negative pressure wound therapy for open traumatic wounds.
,
[44]- Costa M.L.
- Achten J.
- Bruce J.
- Tutton E.
- Petrou S.
- Lamb S.
- et al.
Effect of negative pressure wound therapy versus standard wound management on 12-month disability among adults with severe open fracture of the lower limb: the WOLFF randomized clinical trial.
]. While NPWT is widely available in the operating room, this method of wound coverage may not be an adequate substitute to soft-tissue coverage [
[45]Open fractures with soft-tissue loss: coverage options and timing of surgery.
]. Further, this survey did not distinguish between industry manufactured and improvised NPWT devices, the latter of which is used in some public hospitals in Latin America and has an efficacy that has not been well described. Additional investigation on the differences between NPWT devices would be beneficial. In HICs, surgeons in Latin America were predisposed to treat lower extremity proximal third, middle third, and distal third defects more commonly with free flaps, likely due to the greater access to plastic surgeons at their institutions. Conversely, surgeons in MICs more commonly treated these injuries with various other methods, including fasciocutaneous flaps, local muscle flaps, or direct wound care. While there is evidence to support that free flaps can lead to less wound complications for fractures with high grade osseus injuries [
[46]- Pollak A.N.
- McCarthy M.L.
- Burgess A.R.
Short-term wound complications after application of flaps for coverage of traumatic soft-tissue defects about the tibia. The Lower Extremity Assessment Project (LEAP) Study Group.
], Cho et al. reported no differences in healing or infection rates between fasciocutaenous and muscle flaps, describing both as suitable procedures for wound coverage [
[47]Early microsurgical reconstruction of complex trauma of the extremities.
,
[48]- Parikh P.M.
- Hall M.M.
- Attinger C.E.
- Masden D.L.
- Steinberg J.S.
External fixation: indications in lower extremity reconstruction and limb salvage.
]. Though the decision for type of flap coverage is dependent on the location and severity of the defect [
[37]- Elniel A.R.
- Giannoudis P.V.
Open fractures of the lower extremity: current management and clinical outcomes.
], further examination of the regional differences in soft-tissue treatment selection could help to identify areas of change to improve clinical outcomes.
This large-scale multi-national study describes orthopaedic surgeons’ soft-tissue coverage techniques of open tibia fractures in Latin America, with the intent to provide insight into region-specific knowledge gaps. Nineteen countries were represented in this study, providing a broad overview of regional treatment patterns and availability of wound care resources. The study demonstrated that most respondents had limited access to necessary soft-tissue coverage surgical tools and resources, most orthopaedic surgeons in this region have received no soft-tissue training, and HICs and MICs have different access to plastic surgeons and expectations for flap type and timing to definitive coverage.
This study had several limitations. First, a chain-referral sampling method was utilized to improve the number of responses, precluding the ability to estimate a survey response rate. However, this method allowed the survey to be distributed more widely and to a more diverse group of orthopaedic surgeons across the region. Second, the overall number of 469 survey responses was low in comparison to the actual number of practicing orthopaedic surgeons in Latin America, limiting the generalizability of the results. Though it is difficult to provide an absolute number of practicing orthopaedic surgeons across the region, a total of 30,000 orthopaedic surgeon-members have been estimated across 20 Latin American national societies. [
[25]- Albright P.D.
- MacKechnie M.C.
- Roberts H.J.
- Shearer D.W.
- Padilla Rojas L.G.
- Quintero J.E.
- et al.
Open tibial shaft fractures: treatment patterns in Latin America.
]. Nevertheless, the survey represented participants from 19 countries in Latin America, providing for a regional evaluation of soft-tissue treatment techniques . Third, there were few responses collected overall from the HICs, which may not adequately reflect the treatment practices across this entire income group and may affect statistical inferences. These fewer responses are due, in large part, to the fact that there are only two countries designated as HICs in Latin America (Chile and Uruguay); it is valuable, however, to include these data to fully understand management differences in the region.
In summary, this study's findings support the need for soft-tissue training courses, including rotational flaps, skin graft, and wound management, as well as better allocation of surgical tools and resources for orthopaedic surgeons in this region. Further investigation into differences in the clinical outcomes related to soft-tissue coverage methods and protocols can provide additional insight into the importance of timing and access to specialists.
Corporate Authors
RafaelAmadei, MD
1 (
[email protected]),Fernando Baldy dos Reis, MD
2(
[email protected]), Paulo R. Barbosa Lourenco, MD
3(
[email protected]), Renny Cárdenas Quintero, MD
4(
[email protected]), Fernando de la Huerta, MD
5(
[email protected]), Bibiana Dello Russo, MD
6(
[email protected]), Igor A. Escalante Elguezabal, MD
7(
[email protected]), Robinson Esteves Pires, MD
8(
[email protected]), Diego Abraham Estrada Tellez, MD
9(
[email protected]), Nicolas Gaggero, MD
10(
[email protected]), Germán Garabano, MD
11 (
[email protected]), Erika Guerrero Rodriguez, MD
12 (
[email protected]), Gustavo Hernández Vivas, MD
13 (
[email protected]), Jose María Jiménez Avila, MD, PhD
14(
[email protected]), Kodi E. Kojima, MD, PhD
15(
[email protected]), Leonardo López Almejo, MD
16 (
[email protected]), Roberto López Cervantes, MD
17 (
[email protected]), Aramíz López Durán, MD
18 (
[email protected]), Gerardo López Mejia, MD
19 (
[email protected]), Ricardo Madrigal Gutiérrez, MD
20 (
[email protected]), Jose Martínez Ruíz, MD
21 (
[email protected]), Claudia Medina, MD
22(
[email protected]), Edgar E. Mercado Salcedo, MD
23 (
[email protected]), Saúl Mingüer Vargas, MD
24(
[email protected]), Tomás Minueza, MD
25 (
[email protected]), Eduardo Octaviano Navarro Martínez, MD
26 (
[email protected]), Maura Ocampo Vega, MD
27 (
[email protected]), María Elena Pérez Carrera, MD
28 (
[email protected]), César Pesciallo, MD
29(
[email protected]), Luiz Henrique Penteado da Silva, MD
30(
[email protected]), Claudia Ramirez, MD
31 (
[email protected]), Marcelo Rio, MD
32 (
[email protected]), Jesús Rodriguez López, MD
33 (
[email protected]), Alberto J Serrano F, MD
34 (
[email protected]), Santiago Svarzchtein, MD
35 (
[email protected]), Victor Toledo-Infanson, MD
36 (
[email protected]), Miguel Triana, MD
37 (
[email protected]), Jorge Verlarde, MD
38 (
[email protected]), Eduardo Vilensky, MD
39 (
[email protected]), Mauricio Zuluaga, MD
40 (
[email protected]).
1Hospital Cuenca Alta Cañuelas, Argentina, 2EPM-UNIFESP, 3Hospital Quinta D'or, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 4Sociedad Venezolana de Cirugía Ortopédica y Traumatología, Hospital Central de San Cristóbal, 5Hospital Country 2000, 6Hospital Nacional de Pediatría, Profesor J.P. Garrahan, Argentina, 7Hospital Universitario de Caracas, Venezuela, 8Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil, 9Hospital Civil Fray Antonio Alcalde, Mexico, 10Hospital del Trabajador, 11Hospital Británico de Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina, 12Hospital Universitario José Eleutario Gonzalez, 13IHSS, Hospital Fundación Ruth Paz, 14Institute Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey, Campus Guadalajara, Guadalajara, Jalisco, México, 15Hospital das Clínicas HCFMUSP, Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade de Sao Paulo, Sao Paulo, Brazil, 16Federación Mexicana de Colegios de Ortopedia y Traumatología A.C, Hospital Star Médica, Aguascalientes, Mexico, 17Hospital de Especialidades San Francisco de Asis, 18Instituto Nacional de Pediatria, 19Hospital Christus Muguerza Saltillo, 20Hospital Puerta de Hierro, Mexico, 21Hospital Civil Fray Antonio Alcade, Mexico, 22IPS Universitaria Clinica Leon XIII, Colombia, 23Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social, Mexico, 24Hospital Regional Presidente, Juárez del ISSSTE, Oaxaca, Mexico, 25Hospital Fundación Ruth Paz, 26Hospital General Dr. Aurelio Valdivieso, 27Hospital General, Regional Número 20, Tijuana BC, México, 28Clínica Tramatología y Ortopedia Pediatrica, Universidad de la República Uruguay, 29Hospital Británico de Buenos Aires, 30Clínica IOT e HSVP de Passo Fundo, RS, Brazil, 31Puerta de Hierro, 32Clínica Zabala, Argentina, 33Centro de Investigación y Docencia en Ciencias de la Salud, Universidad Autonoma de Sinaloa, Mexico, 34Universidad Central de Venezuela, Facultad de Medicina, Escuela de Medicina José María Vargas, Caracas, Venezuela, 35Centro Médico Integral Fitz Roy, Argentina, 36Hospital General Gua Prieta, SSA, 37Fundación Cardioinfantil, Hospital Infantil de San José y Clínica la Colina, Colombia, 38Hospital Santo Tomás, Panama, 39CASMUS, Asociación Española, Uruguay, 40Clínica Imbanaco.